Understanding Claw Toe: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options

Claw toe is a prevalent foot condition characterized by toes curling downward, resembling a claw-like shape. This deformity often causes the toes to press against the soles of your shoes, leading to discomfort and the formation of painful calluses. Without proper intervention, claw toe can progressively worsen, potentially resulting in a permanent deformity. Early diagnosis and treatment are crucial to prevent long-term complications and improve mobility

Anatomy

The forefoot consists of five toes, with each toe having three joints, except for the big toe, which typically has only two. In cases of claw toe, the affected toe bends abnormally at two key joints: the middle joint, known as the proximal interphalangeal (PIP) joint, and the last joint, called the distal interphalangeal (DIP) joint.

Causes

Claw toe is often associated with wearing footwear that constrains the toes, such as high heels or shoes that are too short. However, it is also commonly linked to nerve damage caused by conditions like diabetes, stroke, or chronic alcoholism, which weaken the foot’s muscles over time. Additionally, trauma or chronic inflammation can contribute to the development of this deformity.

Symptoms

Signs of claw toe include upward bending (extension) of the toe at the joints near the ball of the foot, combined with downward bending (flexion) at the middle joint toward the sole of the shoe. In some cases, the top joint of the toe may also curl downward, causing the toe to tuck under the foot. This abnormal positioning often leads to the formation of corns on the top of the toe or calluses under the ball of the foot, resulting in discomfort or pain.

 

This claw toe digs down toward the sole of the shoe.

Doctor Examination

If you experience symptoms of claw toe, it’s essential to consult a doctor for a thorough evaluation. Diagnostic tests may be required to rule out neurological conditions that could weaken foot muscles and lead to imbalances causing the toes to bend. Trauma and inflammation are other potential causes of this deformity. Identifying the underlying issue is crucial, as it directly influences the treatment approach.

During the examination, your doctor will determine whether the clawing is flexible or rigid. In the early stages, claw toe deformities are typically flexible, but over time they can become stiff and fixed in place. Additionally, your doctor will assess the skin on your foot for calluses or breakdown, as these factors can impact the recommended treatment plan.

Treatment

For claw toe in its early stages, your doctor may suggest using a splint or tape to help hold the toes in their proper position. To alleviate discomfort and prevent progression, consider the following advice:

  • Opt for shoes with soft, spacious toe boxes that allow ample room for your toes, and avoid tight-fitting shoes or high heels.
  • Use your hands to gently stretch your toes and joints, encouraging them back to their normal alignment.
  • Engage in toe-strengthening exercises, such as:
    • Picking up marbles from the floor using your toes.
    • Performing towel curls by placing a towel flat under your foot and using your toes to scrunch it.

 

Doing “towel curls” can help strengthen the toes and restore muscle balance.

Treatment for Advanced Claw Toe

If claw toe progresses to later stages and the toes become rigid or fixed in position, specific treatments can help alleviate symptoms and reduce discomfort:

  • Redistribute Pressure: Special pads can be used to redistribute your weight and relieve pressure on the ball of your foot.
  • In-Depth Shoes: Consider “in-depth” shoes, which offer an additional 3/8″ of depth in the toe box to accommodate the deformity.
  • Custom Shoe Modifications: A shoe repair shop can stretch the toe box to create a pocket that provides extra space for the affected toes.

When these conservative measures fail to provide relief, surgical intervention may be necessary.

Surgical Treatment

The surgical approach depends on the flexibility and severity of the claw toe deformity:

  • Flexible Claw Toe: For flexible deformities, the surgeon may release or cut the tendon on the underside of the toe. This procedure helps alleviate pressure and prevent sores or ulcers on the toe tip.
  • Rigid Claw Toe: For rigid deformities, the surgical approach often involves a combination of techniques:
    • Tendon lengthening or release to improve flexibility.
    • Shortening one of the toe bones or fusing the middle toe joint (arthrodesis) to correct alignment and stabilize the toe.
    • A pin may be temporarily placed in the toe for 4 to 6 weeks to secure the bones during the healing process.

In a fusion, a small amount of bone is first removed from the PIP joint (Left). A metal pin has been inserted to hold the bones in place until they fuse (Right).

 

This patient’s toes have been corrected with arthrodesis (fusion). A metal pin has been inserted in each toe to hold the bones in place while they fuse. Plastic caps have been placed over the tips of the pins.

Post-Surgery Recovery

After claw toe surgery, it is common to experience some stiffness, swelling, and redness in the affected toe, typically lasting for 4 to 6 weeks. These symptoms gradually subside as the healing process progresses.

During the recovery period, you may be able to bear weight on your heel for short distances. However, extended walking is generally discouraged to avoid strain and facilitate healing. Elevating your foot as often as possible can help reduce swelling, alleviate discomfort, and promote faster recovery.

Once the healing is complete, you may notice slight changes in the appearance or function of your toe. The toe might be marginally longer or shorter than before, and the fused joint will no longer bend. While this limits flexibility, the procedure effectively alleviates pain and prevents further complications.

Scroll to Top